Adverse Events Do Not Outweigh Benefits of Combination Therapy for Crohn's Disease in a Decision Analytic Model

Background & Aims

The Study of Biologic and Immunomodulator-Naïve Patients With Crohn's Disease (SONIC) showed that combination therapy with infliximab and azathioprine (IFX/AZA) is more effective than treatment with IFX alone. Numbers and types of adverse events were roughly equivalent among groups, although enrollment was limited, so it was not clear how rare adverse events might affect overall outcomes in practice. We sought to define the frequency at which a rare adverse event would have to occur for the risks of combination therapy to outweigh the benefits of treatment.

Methods

We constructed a decision model to compare the risks and benefits of IFX/AZA with IFX monotherapy. Model parameters were taken from SONIC and other published literature. The base-case analysis was patients with active Crohn's disease who are naïve to both medications (similar to those in SONIC) who were treated for 1 year. We used sensitivity analyses to determine the thresholds at which the risks of side effects from IFX/AZA outweigh its benefits.

Results

During 1 year, the benefits of IFX/AZA would outweigh the risks, unless serious infections occurred in 20% or more of the population or lymphoma in 3.9% or more. These thresholds are 5-fold and 65-fold higher than base-case estimates, respectively.

Conclusions

On the basis of data from 1 year of SONIC, the combination of IFX/AZA was more effective than IFX alone in patients with Crohn's disease who are naïve to either drug. For the risks of combination therapy to outweigh the benefits in this time frame, the incidence of serious adverse events would have to be higher than seems clinically realistic.

Keywords:  Inflammation , Anti-Tumor Necrosis Factor (TNF) Agent , Side Effect , Intestine , IBD , Complication

Abbreviations used in this paper:  AZA, azathioprine, IFX, infliximab, NHL, non-Hodgkin's lymphoma, QALY, quality-adjusted life-years, SAE, serious adverse event, SEER, Surveillance, Epidemiology and End Results, SONIC, Study of Biologic and Immunomodulator-Naïve Patients With Crohn's Disease, TNF, tumor necrosis factor